A First Breastfeeding Experience with Impostor Syndrome

Looking back, I’m all in all pretty happy with how my breastfeeding journey went. We often hear stories about breastfeeding, each less rosy than the last, and honestly, I had prepared myself for anything. It was something I wanted to succeed at for my child’s sake, and I’m happy it worked. My journey wasn’t perfect. I was often judged because I wasn’t breastfeeding “for real”; you’ll understand soon…

This article may contain affiliate links. If you book or buy through them, we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting Sparks and Bloom!

So, before I start, I want to tell you that a fed baby and a happy mom are, in my heart, what matter more than anything. You tried it and it didn’t work, you found success, you alternated with the bottle, you’re a mom who pumps her milk: your story belongs to you, and what matters is that you can live well with it. #FedIsBest

THE FIRST DAYS

I give birth to my baby, a bit like in my dreams. It’s more than perfect, I’m happy, baby is doing well, everything is going smoothly. We put him to the breast 30 minutes after he’s born. Apart from unpleasant comments from the nurse, who doesn’t believe I’ll manage because my nipples are a little flat, the first feed goes well. My midwife set the nurse aside to give me a few tips, and after a few tries I manage to get him to drink. The night goes on, baby drinks once more, then he starts having trouble latching.

As I mentioned a little in my birth story, which you can read right here, we’ll never really know why he stopped latching after his first 2 feeds. The nurses told me he was exhausted from coming into the world, but funnily enough, nobody rushed to try to put him back to the breast. I kind of regret it, because for a long time I thought it could have saved those first months… I’d learn later that it was more than that.

So we go home with baby, and he still really doesn’t want to take my breast. That’s when I bring out the nipple shield. That little piece of plastic that ended up saving my breastfeeding. If you want to see what it looks like or order a nipple shield.

Baby takes it right away. So I continue the next few feeds with the nipple shield, while still trying to offer him the breast first, but he doesn’t want it.

MIXED OPINIONS ON THE NIPPLE SHIELD

For 2 months, I felt like an impostor. Truly.

According to many people, “I wasn’t really breastfeeding.” And yet my baby never got a single drop of formula. Right!?

But there’s so much pressure around breastfeeding that needing a nipple shield felt a bit like we had failed. That’s why I insisted on telling you that #FedIsBest. You’re doing your best, and I know it.

On the very first night, my husband books an appointment with a lactation consultant. She’ll come see us on day 4. Very quickly, as you can see. I wanted it to happen fast because I’d read several times that a nipple shield shouldn’t be used for long periods of time.

ON DAY 4

The lactation consultant gives us all the tips, and after many tries and a baby in full meltdown, we manage to get him on the breast without the nipple shield. PHEW! It was quite the workout. I’ll always be grateful to her for not putting pressure on me about using it. She believed in it. She told me: “If you need it, that’s totally fine. It’s a tool, and sometimes we need tools.” So we worked on weaning off the nipple shield because that’s what I wanted, not because she was pressuring me to.

THE HIDDEN SIDE OF THE NIPPLE SHIELD

Many people will think that because I was using a nipple shield, it was “easy” and my breasts weren’t chapped, cracked or bleeding. On the contrary, it hurt.

Some nights I cried in bed because it hurt too much, because he was drinking a few drops of blood with my milk, and add to that the social pressure of being a breastfeeding impostor while postpartum. Let me tell you, it was quite the cocktail! In fact, the pain from using the nipple shield was my main motivation for trying to stop using it.

Then, of course, it has to be cleaned and sterilized every 24 hours. So every 2 hours at night, I was doing my dishes in the bathroom sink. Very glamorous!

But it saved my breastfeeding.

THE MONTHS THAT FOLLOWED

For two and a half months, I tried hard. Every day, I tried to breastfeed him without the nipple shield. Sometimes it worked, sometimes it went badly, sometimes I didn’t have the mental energy to do it, so I let it go.

What crushed me the most was reading this text about nipple shields by Dr. Newman. I rely a lot on this doctor for breastfeeding, and I can understand why he says what he does about nipple shields. But after searching for every possible solution and trying everything for weeks, I was really devastated to read that the nipple shield was like this doctor’s worst enemy. He didn’t see fit to mention the positive points of this tool; instead, he insisted on listing everything wrong with nipple shields, mentioning of course that it wasn’t real breastfeeding. I spent the night crying and wondering why I had read that article.

Everyone tells you breastfeeding is beautiful, and to be honest, at 4 months postpartum, I’m only just starting to see the beauty. At the beginning, there are a lot of lows and few highs, then it gets better, becoming almost all highs as the weeks go by. That’s when you see the real beauty of breastfeeding. When you admire your little one being nourished by you, his little smiles between sips, his laughter after feeds while still snuggled at your breast, not to mention how easy it is to feed your child anywhere and anytime you want. It’s simply priceless.

témoignage premier allaitement allaiter téterelle

THE TURNING POINT

I was starting to get used to my new life as a breastfeeding-impostor mom. My baby wanted to nurse without the nipple shield more and more, but as soon as he did it for more than a few feeds, my breasts hurt a lot. When I talked about it, people told me it was normal, but honestly, I knew it wasn’t. I had a little feeling that something was off. I had a third appointment with my lactation consultant to go over the latch again and really try everything.

But it still hurt; after a few feeds I’d put the nipple shield back on. I couldn’t take it anymore.

Then a friend told me about a professional who works with breastfed babies, so we booked a craniosacral therapy appointment.

It took one appointment. The moment she put her finger in my baby’s mouth, she immediately understood what I’d been trying to explain to everyone for months. It was a bit like his suck was “crooked.” He was nursing at an angle to the left. My breast clearly wasn’t going to the right place when he tried to nurse without the nipple shield. And I always felt he couldn’t get the milk out properly, since he was often hungry 30 minutes after a feed at the breast without the shield.

Following his arrival into the world, his jaw was completely out of place. That explains why it was almost impossible for him to drink directly from the breast and why it was torture for me every time. What was strange is that it didn’t hurt during the feed, but in the hour that followed, I’d see bruises, swelling and cracks appear all over my breasts. That made the next feed at the breast impossible for me. And using the nipple shield helped him get the milk, since it’s big and bulky in the mouth.

Seriously, she worked miracles. For a good hour, she worked on realigning his mouth and palate.

  1. 12. HOURS. LATER….

The nipple shield was already a thing of the past. I say 12 hours because he was so exhausted from his appointment that I kept using the nipple shield until the next morning. Then I put him to the breast as if nothing had happened, as if he’d always nursed that way. And I never used the nipple shield again. Incredible, eh!

I’m telling you about it and I still can’t believe it.

And my breasts never hurt again. #NoJoke

AND NOW! 

Baby has now been nursing directly at the breast for 6 weeks. I’ve put my nipple shields far away, because after that appointment they were no longer needed. Seeing my baby feed directly at the breast is quite an accomplishment for me. And I have to say I was wrong to listen to and read all those words that were, in my opinion, mistaken about using a nipple shield.

I understand the idea is to have the baby right up against us, but we mustn’t forget that these tools were created for a reason: to help us. I also understand that they shouldn’t be the solution to our problems, but in my case, I don’t think I would have kept breastfeeding without the nipple shield. I don’t think I would have been mentally strong enough to pump my milk and give it to baby at every feed for two and a half months before finally putting him to the breast.

The nipple shield gave me the closeness I so needed with my baby. To me, he was at the breast. To me, I wasn’t a fake breastfeeding mom. And I know that despite everything, I gave him the best of me, even if my milk passed through a little piece of plastic before reaching his mouth for a few weeks.

So, to you who are breastfeeding a little outside the norm: know that I feel you. And no matter what others may tell you, you’re not an impostor. On the contrary, you’re an extraordinary mom for looking for all these solutions to feed your baby the best way possible.

Oh yes! And to heck with the judgment.

What if instead we gave each other the chance to succeed without judgment?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like